TSB 061: Should I Quit? Imposter Syndrome vs. Reality for Non-Profit Leaders.

leadership nonprofit the saturday boardroom Mar 02, 2024
TSB 061: Should I Quit? Imposter Syndrome vs. Reality for Non-Profit Leaders.

You're leading a passionate team, making a difference in the world, and facing down challenges with the tenacity of a superhero. Sounds pretty darn impressive, right? Yet, a nagging voice whispers: "But am I even qualified? What if I'm just faking it?"

Welcome to the not-so-exclusive club of imposter syndrome in the CEO world. It's a surprisingly common experience, where despite your accomplishments, doubt creeps in, making you feel like a fraud waiting to be exposed.

But why does this happen, especially to high-achieving individuals like you?

It's a Recipe of Pressure and Perfectionism:

  • High-stakes environment: You're responsible for the well-being of your organization, its mission, and the people it serves. The pressure to succeed can be immense.
  • Comparison trap: Scrolling through LinkedIn and seeing other "successful" leaders can fuel the fire, leading to a distorted view of reality and feelings of inadequacy.
  • Internalized perfectionism: The bar you set for yourself can be impossibly high. You focus on what you haven't achieved, overlooking the mountain you've already climbed.

So, how do we conquer this imposter and reclaim our power?

  • Challenge the narrative: When the "imposter voice" starts its tirade, question its validity. Ask yourself: "Is this thought helpful? Are my accomplishments really a fluke?" Often, a reality check helps silence the negativity.
  • Focus on facts, not feelings: When self-doubt creeps in, list your achievements, big or small. This concrete evidence acts as a much-needed counterweight to subjective feelings of inadequacy.
  • Seek support: Talk to other nonprofit leaders! You'd be surprised at how many share similar experiences. Building a supportive network can provide valuable insights and remind you, you're not alone.
  • Celebrate wins, big and small: Acknowledge your accomplishments, no matter how seemingly insignificant. Every success, every challenge overcome, is a testament to your capability.

Remember, leading a nonprofit is a complex and demanding role. Feeling challenged and unsure at times is completely normal. The key is to recognize the imposter for what it is – a self-doubting voice – and focus on the incredible work you and your team are doing. You've got this!

That's all for today. I'll see you again next Saturday!


Whenever you're ready, there are three ways we can help you:

  1. Register for one of our upcoming workshops here. 
  2. Learn the strengths and growth areas for your team and its members here.
  3. Get expert advice to help transform the culture of your organization and develop better leaders here. 

Want Helpful Tips on Workplace Culture?

Join the nonprofit leaders who benefit from our weekly insights.

You're safe with us. We'll never spam you or sell your contact info.