TSB 032: The State of Nonprofits: An Analysis of Trends in 2023
Jun 10, 2023
Read Time: 5 minutes
This week's tip: Here are nine trends for 2023 to follow and position yourself to get ahead of the curve. 
In the ever-evolving nonprofit landscape, staying up-to-date with the latest trends and developments has become crucial for organizations to thrive. As we approach the second half of 2023, the nonprofit sector faces a myriad of challenges, including record inflation, workforce shortages, potential recession, and declining donations.
In this article, we will delve into the state of nonprofits and analyze the emerging trends that will shape their future. Grab a cup of coffee, sit back, and let's explore the trends together.
1. Navigating Economic Uncertainty
One of the most pressing concerns for nonprofits in 2023 is the looming uncertainty around the economy. With mixed financial data, it's challenging to predict if an economic recession is on the horizon. While average wages increased by 4.5% in 2022, they failed to keep up with the 6.5% inflation rate. The stock market experienced an 18% loss in 2022 but bounced back with a 7% gain in the first quarter of 2023. With 9.9 million job openings as of the last report, 5.5 million people are still searching for work.
To navigate this uncertainty, nonprofits should devise fundraising strategies for different economic scenarios, such as no recession, mild recession, and severe recession. These scenarios should focus on modifications to types of events, messaging, price points, and using data to quantify the needs. Remember that charitable giving typically declines by only 0.5% (after inflation) during a recession. However, it's crucial for nonprofits to err on the side of caution and prioritize financial sustainability.
Record inflation has put significant pressure on nonprofits as they grapple with increased payrolls and operational costs. With limited resources and chronic understaffing, staff members may become frustrated and seek employment elsewhere.
To combat this challenge, nonprofits might focus on workplace culture, reducing friction in day-to-day responsibilities, and streamlining processes.
2. Addressing Workforce Challenges
Nonprofits, like their for-profit counterparts, face workforce challenges as they compete for top talent in a demanding job market. With 86% of nonprofits reporting difficulties retaining employees, it's essential to find innovative ways to attract and keep skilled workers. One way to achieve this is by igniting your team's passion and equipping them with the tools and resources they need to champion your cause. You’ve heard me talk about The Predictive Index, and the tools it provides to address the four forces of disengagement.
As the workforce landscape continues to shift, nonprofits need to consider alternative staffing options to stay ahead. Fractional staffing, which offers part-time or temporary positions, can provide a viable solution for nonprofits struggling to fill vacancies or seeking cost-effective ways to scale their workforce.
3. Embracing Diverse Communication Channels
With demographic shifts influencing how nonprofits communicate with prospects and donors, it's crucial to adopt diversified communication strategies. Email marketing still accounts for one-third of online fundraising revenue, and organizations are six times more likely to receive a click-through from an email than from Instagram. While social media offers excellent opportunities for raising cause awareness, its organic reach is relatively low compared to other fundraising channels.
To resonate with donors, especially millennials, nonprofits must focus on storytelling and showcasing the impact of their work. Millennials are more likely to donate if they can see their contribution making a difference and relate to the cause on a personal level. By emphasizing the lives of those you're helping instead of your organization, you can inspire donors to give and engage with your cause.
4. Adapting to Technological Innovations
In today's fast-paced digital landscape, staying ahead of the technology curve is vital for nonprofits. Generative AI and other emerging technologies offer tremendous potential for stakeholder messaging, but they also raise ethical questions and privacy concerns. To stay competitive, nonprofits must make technology adoption a core competency and leverage its benefits while mitigating risks.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming the nonprofit sector by offering innovative solutions for donor management, prospect research, and stewardship. By applying AI and machine learning to organizational data, nonprofits can precisely identify target audiences and deliver tailored messaging that aligns with their interests. Embracing AI can help nonprofits optimize their fundraising efforts, streamline operations, and enhance donor engagement.
5. Tackling the Challenges of Pandemic-Era Donor Retention
During the pandemic, many nonprofits experienced an increase in donor acquisition and average gift sizes. As donor acquisition declines, it's crucial for organizations to engage these donors effectively to drive lifetime value and maintain retention rates. Successful nonprofits will recognize the importance of nurturing these relationships and take proactive measures to retain and grow their donor base.
6. Expanding Nonprofit Boards
As nonprofits face a crowded and competitive social sector, boards must become more sophisticated to navigate the challenges ahead. In 2023, we may see organizations seeking board members with diverse skill sets, such as business, legal, technology, and digital marketing expertise. By expanding their boards with professionals from various backgrounds, nonprofits can better address complex issues and drive strategic growth.
7. Exploring Virtual and Hybrid Events
As in-person events make a comeback, virtual and hybrid events should not be overlooked. These events offer several benefits, such as overcoming geographical limitations, increasing reach, and limiting costs on travel and other expenditures. Pandemic-era trends like Gaming for Good and Streaming for Good continue to be effective ways to engage new donors and reach broader audiences.
8. Focusing on Transformational Giving
Transformational giving is an emerging trend in the nonprofit sector, particularly for social equity-based organizations. To capitalize on this trend, nonprofits should shift their approach to strategy, data collection, and impact storytelling. Additionally, optimizing key operations will ensure organizations are positioned to scale and maximize the benefits of transformational gifts.
9. Leveraging Donor-Advised Funds (DAFs)
While DAFs are not new, their influence on the nonprofit sector is growing. Individual donors account for 67% of all funds given, with much of the giving from foundations attributed to DAFs or closely held family foundations. To maximize the potential of DAFs, nonprofits should ensure their gift acceptance policies and acknowledgment practices provide guidance for accepting these gifts and thanking the donor or advisor.
Overall, the state of nonprofits in 2023 presents both challenges and opportunities. By staying informed about emerging trends and adapting their strategies accordingly, nonprofits can continue to make a meaningful impact in their communities.
We hope this comprehensive analysis has provided you with valuable insights to help your organization navigate the complex world of nonprofits and thrive in the second half of 2023 and beyond.
That's all for today. I'll see you again next Saturday!
Whenever you're ready, there are three ways we can help you: